While many like to view Capitol’s (as well as Vee Jay and United Artists) modifying of The Beatles Parlophone albums, these repackagings are rarely deserving of such scoldings. So i’m going to go through album by album and see who’s the winner.
Let’s start with The Beatles first album Please Please Me. At first, Vee Jay was planning on releasing the album in tact. However, due to legal issues the release was delayed until The Beatles signed to Capitol. Realizing what they had, they removed Please Please Me and Ask Me Why (as well as snipping off the start of I Saw Her Standing There) and released it as Introducing…The Beatles. However, they were unable to include Love Me Do and P.S. I Love You due to unpaid royalties so they swapped out those 2 for the 2 they had originally omitted.
Once Capitol finally gained the rights to the Please Please Me album in late 1964, they decided to cut out I Saw Her Standing There (which was already on Meet The Beatles!), Misery, and There’s A Place as well as move Love Me Do and Twist And Shout to the beginning and move Do You Want To Know A Secret to the end making The Early Beatles.
Here’s my rankings:
#1 Introducing…The Beatles (revision)
#2 Please Please Me
#3 Introducing…The Beatles (original)
#4 The Early Beatles
Love Me Do is easily one of the worst songs in The Beatles catalog and P.S. I Love You is okay but nothing special so i really like how these 2 songs are excluded from the revision of Introducing…The Beatles. The Early Beatles is last due to the unnecessary amount of rearranging done.
Next up is With The Beatles. While Capitol of Canada left this album in tact, Capitol of America created Meet The Beatles! by taking out the rock and roll covers and opening the album with I Want To Hold Your Hand (the hit single at the time), I Saw Her Standing There (the US B-side), and This Boy (the UK B-side).
Meet The Beatles! is by far the superior album. I Want To Hold Your Hand is a way better opener than I Saw Her Standing There, the tracks flow better, and even the cover looks nicer with that colorful blue tint. Don’t get me wrong, With The Beatles is still a good album but Meet The Beatles! is a great album and it’s a real shame this is the album Canada got in tact.
Now on to A Hard Day’s Night. Capitol was originally going to issue a 12 track album with all 7 of the film songs plus 5 new songs but United Artists rushed out their soundtrack album which contains both Beatles and orchestral songs, leaving Capitol to create Something New, which consists of side B of A Hard Day’s Night minus You Can’t Do That (already on The Beatles Second Album) and I’ll Be Back and moving Any Time At All after Things We Said Today followed by Slow Down and Matchbox from the Long Tall Sally EP followed by tracks 3-6 on A Hard Day’s Night in reverse order and then ending with the German version of I Want To Hold Your Hand.
My ranking:
#1 A Hard Day’s Night (Parlophone)
#2 A Hard Day’s Night (United Artists)
#3 Something New
Something New is a terrible hackjob that would’ve been best left scrapped. On top of the over the top shuffling of the tracks, I’ll Cry Instead and all of Side B had been previously released on the UA soundtrack (or Meet The Beatles! in the case of I Want To Hold Your Hand). That being said, the UK version reigns supreme. The soundtrack is nice and i do enjoy the score but when i listen to a Beatles album, i want to hear The Beatles, not the George Martin Orchestra.
Next up is Beatles For Sale. Here in the US we got the first 6 tracks plus the Ringo and George tracks and the other tracks replaced with I’ll Be Back, She’s A Woman, and I Feel Fine, which were placed in between Ringo’s song and George’s song.
Beatles ’65 is the winner in my book. I love side A of Beatles For Sale but side B isn’t quite as good so it’s great to see that Capitol took that stuff out and replaced it with the hit single and the super underrated closer to A Hard Day’s Night.
I’m not a big fan of Help! but i’ll take the UK album any day over the US album with that awful Indian score.
When it comes to Rubber Soul, people really seem to love the US album, which takes out Drive My Car, Nowhere Man, What Goes On?, and If I Needed Someone and open side A with I’ve Just Seen A Face and side B with It’s Only Love.
While Capitol certainly did a good job in making an alternative to the UK version, the UK version wins. I really like the 4 songs they omitted way better than the 2 songs they added, especially Nowhere Man.
UK Revolver is better than US Revolver. All Capitol did was remove 3 tracks that were already on Yesterday And Today, leaving John with only 2 songs.
US Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band is better than UK Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band because there’s no nonsensical inner groove to ruin the tranquility of the final E chord.
US Magical Mystery Tour is better than the UK double EP. In the UK you have to put the disc in, flip it over to the other side, change the disc, and flip it to other side once again for only NINETEEN MINUTES of music. Fortunately, Capitol was smart enough to put the 6 movie songs on one side and the 5 1967 singles on the other and even the UK’s been using this Capitol compilation for the past 43 years.
For The BEATLES and Abbey Road, Capitol removed some of the bass frequencies to make it easier to master. UK kept the bass and is therefore the winner.
For Yellow Submarine, the music is the exact same (at least on vinyl) but the US has a better back cover. While the UK had a review for The BEATLES on the back cover, the US has a fictional story about the movie on the back.
Finally, Let It Be came with a book in the UK but not in the US.
Overall, the UK is the winner but i still think the US albums are typically great albums.